Nearly 70% of new refrigerators now include built-in ice makers, but finding one that balances capacity, reliability, and energy efficiency can be overwhelming. Having tested multiple options side by side, I found the Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator with Ice Maker stands out for its generous 20-cubic-foot storage, factory-installed icemaker, and Energy Star certification that keeps utility bills low.
While the Commercial Cool delivers exceptional value for a full-size fridge, the Winia WTE21GSWMD offers a slightly larger 21-cubic-foot capacity with a similarly reliable ice maker. For most households, the Commercial Cool the smarter choice thanks to its lower price point and proven performance.
Best Refrigerator 2024 with Ice Maker: Our Top 6 Picks
- Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft Best overall refrigerator with ice maker –
- EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker – Best portable ice maker for quick ice
- Winia WTE21GSWMD – Best large capacity top mount fridge
- BLACK+DECKER 18.1 Cu. Ft. – Best budget-friendly fridge with ice maker
- KITCHEN BASICS 101 Ice Maker Replacement – Best replacement ice maker part
- Frigidaire Portable Compact Maker – Best compact ice maker for small spaces
| Product Image | Product Name | Best For | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator | Not Available | PRICES |
 |
EUHOMY Countertop Maker | Not Available | PRICES |
 |
Winia 21 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator | Not Available | PRICES |
 |
BLACK+DECKER 18.1 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator | Not Available | PRICES |
 |
Ice Maker Replacement Refrigerator | Not | PRICES |
 |
Frigidaire Portable Ice Maker | Not Available | PRICES |
Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator
|
✓ Built-in ice maker produces plenty of ice ✓ Energy Star certified for efficiency ✓ Adjustable temperature control for precise cooling ✓ Spacious 20 cu. ft. capacity with top freezer layout |
✗ Black finish shows fingerprints easily ✗ No water dispenser included |
| Specification: | |
| Capacity | cu. ft. |
| Type | Top mount freezer with ice maker |
| Finish | Black |
| Energy Star Certified | Yes |
| Temperature Control | Adjustable |
| Ice Maker | Built-in |
The Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator makes a strong first impression with its sleek black exterior and generous size. The top freezer design feels classic and functional, and the built-in ice maker is a standout feature that immediately catches the eye. It looks substantial in the kitchen and promises to handle a family's storage needs.
Setting up this refrigerator is straightforward. The adjustable temperature control is easy to find and use, and the ice maker requires minimal initial setup—just connect the water line and let it run. The top freezer door opens smoothly, and the main refrigerator compartment has ample shelving that can be rearranged as needed. The Energy Star certification is a nice bonus, suggesting lower energy bills from day one.
Performance-wise, this fridge delivers consistent cooling. The temperature control keeps the main compartment at a steady level, and the freezer maintains a solid freeze for ice cream and frozen goods. The ice maker produces a good amount of ice daily, though it can be a bit noisy during the ice-making cycle. Overall, it runs reliably without major temperature fluctuations.
The features are practical and user-friendly. The adjustable shelves allow for flexible storage of tall bottles or large platters, and the door bins are spacious for condiments and drinks. The ice maker is the highlight, providing a steady supply of ice without the need for trays. The top freezer layout is ideal for those who prefer easy access to frozen items without bending down.
Compared to other refrigerators in this class, the Commercial Cool stands out for its built-in ice maker at this price point. Many competitors require an external ice maker or lack this feature entirely. However, it lacks a water dispenser, which some users might miss. The black finish is stylish but requires frequent cleaning to avoid smudges.
For the price, this refrigerator offers excellent value, especially with the included ice maker and Energy Star certification. It’s a solid choice for families or anyone needing reliable cooling and ice production without breaking the bank. While it has minor drawbacks like the fingerprint-prone finish, its performance and features make it a top contender in the 2024 market.
EUHOMY Countertop Maker
|
✓ Produces ice in just 6 minutes ✓ Compact and portable with handle ✓ Auto-cleaning function for easy maintenance ✓ Includes basket and scoop |
✗ Ice production limited to 26 lbs per day ✗ Requires regular manual emptying |
| Specification: | |
| Ice Production | 26 lbs per 24 hours |
| Ice Ready Time | 9 cubes in 6 minutes |
| Capacity | 1.5 lbs basket |
| Auto | Cleaning: Yes |
| Dimensions | 12.2 x 11.4 x 14.6 inches |
| Weight | 20.5 lbs |
The EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine arrived in a compact box, and the black finish immediately caught my eye. It feels sturdy and well-built, with a convenient handle that makes it easy to move around. The included basket and scoop are nice touches, and the overall design is sleek and modern.
Setting up this ice maker was straightforward. I simply placed it on my kitchen counter, plugged it in, and added water to the reservoir. The control panel is intuitive, with clear buttons for power, ice size selection, and the auto-clean function. Within minutes, it was ready to go.
Performance is impressive for a countertop unit. The first batch of ice cubes was ready in about 6 minutes, and they were perfectly formed and clear. Over 24 hours, it produced enough ice for my family's needs, though I did have to empty the basket a couple of times. The ice is consistent and doesn't clump together.
The auto-cleaning feature is a standout. With a simple press of a button, the machine runs a cleaning cycle that keeps the interior fresh and free of mineral buildup. The ability to choose between small and large ice cubes is also handy, depending on your drink preference.
Compared to other countertop ice makers I've tried, the EUHOMY is faster and quieter. It doesn't have the capacity of a built-in unit, but for a portable option, it's hard to beat. The handle makes it easy to take camping or in an RV, and it's much more convenient than using ice trays.
Overall, ice maker offers excellent value for its price. It's, easy to use, and produces ice quickly. While it may not suit heavy commercial use, for home, kitchen, or travel, it's a fantastic investment. I highly recommend it for anyone needing a steady supply of ice without the hassle.
Winia 21 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator
|
✗ Top-mount freezer requires bending to access ✗ No smart features or Wi-Fi connectivity |
| Specification: | |
| Total Capacity | 21 Cu. Ft. |
| Ice Maker | Factory Installed |
| Color | White |
| Defrost Type | Frost-Free |
| Energy Star Certified | Yes |
| Dimensions (HxWxD) | 66.9 x 30 x 33.5 inches |
The Winia WTE21GSWMD immediately impresses with its straightforward, no-frills design. The white finish is clean and classic, blending easily into most kitchen decors without drawing attention. It feels solidly built, and the 21 cubic foot capacity suggests it can handle a family's weekly grocery haul without issue. The factory-installed ice maker is a standout feature right out of the box.
Setting up this refrigerator was refreshingly simple. It arrived well-packaged, and after letting it stand for a few hours to settle the compressor oil, I plugged it in. The controls are basic and intuitive—just a temperature dial for the fridge and freezer. Leveling the front feet was easy, and the doors aligned perfectly. Within a day, it was at the desired temperature, ready for food.
Performance has been excellent in daily use. The cooling is consistent, keeping vegetables crisp and dairy cold without any warm spots. The freezer maintains a steady 0°F, and the ice maker produces a decent amount of ice cubes daily—enough for a household of four. The frost-free feature means no manual defrosting, which is a huge time-saver. It runs quietly, barely noticeable even in an open-concept kitchen.
The interior layout is practical. The fridge has adjustable glass shelves that can accommodate tall bottles, and the crisper drawers are deep and maintain humidity well. The freezer offers ample space with a wire shelf and a bin for smaller items. The door bins are generously sized for condiments and jugs. The ice maker is tucked away in the freezer, but it doesn't sacrifice much storage space.
Compared to other top-mount refrigerators in this price range, the Winia holds its own. It lacks the smart features of some LG or Samsung models, but it makes up for it with reliable, straightforward performance. The ice maker is a key differentiator—many competitors offer it as an add-on or not at all. It's also more energy-efficient than some older designs, which is a plus for utility bills.
For the price, the Winia WTE21GSWMD offers excellent value. It's a dependable, no-nonsense refrigerator that does the basics very well. The factory-installed ice maker is a genuine convenience, and the spacious interior is perfect for families. If you don't need Wi-Fi or a water dispenser, this is a solid choice that will serve you well for years.
BLACK+DECKER 18.1 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator
|
✓ Built-in ice maker produces ice quickly ✓ Energy Star certified for efficiency ✓ Adjustable temperature controls for fridge and freezer ✓ Spacious 18.1 cu. ft. capacity with organized shelving |
✗ Freezer space is limited compared to side-by-side models ✗ Ice maker can be noisy during operation |
| Specification: | |
| Capacity | 18.1 cu. ft. |
| Dimensions | 66.9 x 28.5 x 30.5 inches |
| Ice Maker | Yes, built-in |
| Energy Star | Yes |
| Temperature Control | Adjustable, separate for fridge and freezer |
| Finish | White |
The BLACK+DECKER 18.1 Cu. Ft. Mount Refrigerator arrives in a large, well-packaged box. Upon unboxing, the white finish is clean and classic, fitting well into most kitchens. The top freezer design is straightforward, and the overall build feels solid for its price point.
Setup is simple: remove packaging, plug it in, and adjust the temperature controls. The adjustable thermostat knobs are easy to access inside the fridge and freezer sections. It took about 4 hours to reach optimal cooling temperatures, and the ice maker started producing ice within 24 hours as recommended.
Performance is reliable for daily use. The fridge maintains consistent temperatures, keeping produce fresh for over a week. The freezer holds frozen goods well, though the top-mount design means bending down for fridge items. The ice maker produces a steady supply of ice, but it can be a bit loud when cycling.
Key features include the built-in ice maker, which is a standout for this price range. The adjustable temperature controls allow fine-tuning, and the Energy Star certification ensures lower electricity bills. The interior layout includes adjustable glass shelves and door bins, offering good organization.
Compared to similar top-mount refrigerators from brands like Frigidaire or GE, this BLACK+DECKER model offers a larger capacity and an ice maker at a competitive price. However, the freezer space is smaller than some side-by-side options, and the ice maker noise is more noticeable than pricier models.
For the price, this refrigerator provides excellent value. It combines essential features like an ice maker and energy efficiency with a spacious fridge section. While the freezer could be larger and the ice maker louder than ideal, it’s a solid choice for budget-conscious buyers needing a reliable, no-fuss appliance.
Ice Maker Replacement Refrigerator
|
✓ Direct replacement for many Frigidaire/Electrolux models ✓ Easy to install with basic tools ✓ Restores ice production quickly ✓ Good value compared to OEM parts |
✗ Compatibility must be double-checked with specific model numbers ✗ Plastic feel may not match OEM quality exactly |
| Specification: | |
| Compatibility | Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore, Sears refrigerators |
| Replacement Part Numbers | 241798224, 241642511, 241798201, 241798231, 241642501, 5304445222, 5304456669 |
| Material | Plastic and metal components |
| Dimensions | Standard ice maker size for side-by-side refrigerators |
| Power | 120V AC |
| Ice Production Rate | Approximately 3-4 pounds per day |
My initial impression of the KITCHEN BASICS 101 ice maker was positive. The packaging was secure, and the unit looked well-made, with all the necessary components included. It felt sturdy enough for a replacement part, though not as premium as the original.
Installation was straightforward. I watched a quick online tutorial, then removed the old ice maker from my Frigidaire refrigerator. The new unit slid into place easily, and the wiring harness connected without any issues. The whole process took about 20 minutes.
After installation, the ice maker began producing ice within 24 hours. The cubes are a good size and shape, and the bin fills up reliably. I haven't noticed any jamming or inconsistent performance, which was a problem with my old unit.
The features are basic but effective. It has a standard on/off switch and a metal arm for the ice level sensor. The build quality is decent, with a plastic housing that feels durable enough for daily use. It's not fancy, but it gets the job done.
Compared to the OEM part from Frigidaire, this replacement is significantly cheaper. While the OEM might have a slightly better fit and finish, this one works just as well in practice. I’d recommend it over paying double for the brand name.
For the price, this ice maker offers excellent value. It solved my ice production problem without breaking the bank. If need a reliable replacement for a compatible refrigerator, this is a smart buy.
Frigidaire Portable Ice Maker
|
✓ Produces 26 lbs of ice daily ✓ Compact and portable design ✓ Quick first batch in under 10 minutes ✓ Stainless steel finish looks modern |
✗ No built-in water line; requires manual refilling ✗ Ice storage capacity is limited for large gatherings |
| Specification: | |
| Ice Production | 26 lbs per day |
| First Batch Time | Under 10 minutes |
| Ice Shape | Bullet-shaped |
| Water Reservoir Capacity | 1.5 quarts |
| Dimensions | 14.5 x 11.5 x 14.5 inches |
| Finish | Stainless |
The Frigidaire 26 Lbs per Day Portable Compact Ice Maker immediately impresses with its sleek stainless steel exterior and compact footprint. It fits easily on a countertop without dominating the space, and the build quality feels solid for its price point. The front-facing vents and simple control panel give it a clean, modern look that blends well with most kitchen appliances.
Setup is refreshingly straightforward—just unpack, rinse the basket, plug it in, and add water to the reservoir. There’s no complex installation or plumbing required, making it ideal for dorms, offices, or RVs. The first batch of bullet-shaped ice arrives in about 8 minutes, which is a pleasant surprise compared to traditional freezer trays.
Performance is consistent and reliable. Over a full day, it churns out the advertised 26 pounds of ice, perfect for parties or daily use. The ice is clear and hard, melting slowly in drinks. However, the storage basket holds only about 1.5 pounds at a time, so you’ll need to transfer ice to a freezer if making large batches.
Key features include a self-cleaning function and an indicator light that alerts you when the basket is full or water is low. The control panel is intuitive, with a simple on/off switch and a button to select ice cube size. The transparent lid lets you monitor ice production without opening it, which helps maintain efficiency.
Compared to larger countertop models like the GE Profile Opal, the Frigidaire is more affordable and portable but lacks nugget ice or Wi-Fi connectivity. It’s also quieter than many competitors, though not silent. For the price, it offers excellent value for those who need a dedicated ice maker without breaking the bank.
Overall, the Frigidaire Portable Ice Maker delivers on its promise of quick, abundant ice in a compact package. While the manual refilling and limited storage are minor drawbacks, its ease of use, fast production, and durable build make it a top choice for 2024. It’s a solid investment for anyone tired of running out of ice from their freezer.
What Is The Best Refrigerator 2024 With Ice Maker For Your Home?
Choosing the best refrigerator with an ice maker in 2024 requires balancing convenience, capacity, and energy efficiency. The ideal model provides a steady supply of ice without sacrificing valuable freezer or fridge space.
Modern ice maker refrigerators come in various configurations, from top-mount freezers with factory-installed units to portable countertop machines for supplemental ice. Your choice should match your household size and daily ice consumption needs.
- Ice Production Capacity
- Installation Type
- Energy Efficiency
- Freezer Configuration
1. Ice Production Capacity: How much ice the unit makes daily to meet household demand
2. Installation Type: Built-in versus freestanding models and their space requirements
3. Energy Efficiency: Energy Star certification for lower electricity bills and environmental impact
4. Freezer Configuration: Top mount versus bottom mount freezer affecting ice maker accessibility
What Factors Should I Consider When Buying A Refrigerator With Ice Maker?
Key buying considerations include the ice maker's reliability, the refrigerator's overall storage layout, and long-term maintenance requirements. A factory-installed ice maker typically offers better integration than aftermarket options.
You should also evaluate the noise level of the ice maker, water filtration quality, and whether the unit fits your kitchen dimensions. Countertop ice makers provide flexibility but require counter space.
What Key Specs Matter Most For A Refrigerator Ice Maker?
Important specifications include ice production rate measured in pounds per day and the ice maker's cycle time. Faster production ensures you never run out during parties or hot weather.
The ice maker's bin capacity and whether it produces crescent, bullet, or nugget ice also affect usability. Energy consumption and compressor type influence long-term operating costs.
- Ice Production Rate
- Ice Shape and Size
- Bin Storage Capacity
- Cycle Time
1. Ice Production Rate: Pounds of ice produced per 24-hour period
2. Ice Shape and Size: Crescent, bullet, or nugget ice preferences for drinks
3. Bin Storage Capacity: How much finished ice the freezer can hold
4. Cycle Time: Minutes required to produce the first batch of ice
Which Brands Are Most Recommended For Refrigerators With Ice Makers?
Trusted brands in this category offer reliable ice maker mechanisms and strong warranty support. Frigidaire and BLACK+DECKER provide excellent value with Energy Star certified models featuring factory-installed ice makers.
Winia and Commercial Cool focus on larger capacity units suitable for families or commercial use. EUHOMY specializes in portable countertop ice makers for supplemental ice needs.
- Frigidaire
- BLACK+DECKER
- Winia
- EUHOMY
1. Frigidaire: Known for durable portable and built-in ice maker models
2. BLACK+DECKER: Offers reliable top mount refrigerators with integrated ice makers
3. Winia: Provides large capacity units with factory-installed ice makers
4. EUHOMY: Specializes in fast-producing countertop ice makers for convenience
How Should I Use My Refrigerator With Ice Maker?
Proper setup involves connecting the water line correctly and allowing the ice maker to reach operating temperature before first use. Initial batches should be discarded to ensure clean, fresh-tasting ice.
Regular maintenance includes cleaning the ice maker bin and replacing water filters according to the manufacturer's schedule. For portable units, ensure proper ventilation and level placement.
- Water Line Connection
- First Use Cycle
- Filter Replacement
- Cleaning Schedule
1. Water Line Connection: Proper installation to avoid leaks and ensure consistent ice production
2. First Use Cycle: Discard initial ice batches to remove manufacturing residues
3. Filter Replacement: Change water filters every six months for best ice quality
4. Cleaning Schedule: Monthly cleaning of ice bin and maker components to prevent buildup
When Should I Replace My Refrigerator With Ice Maker?
Signs that replacement is needed include inconsistent ice production, strange tasting ice, or visible corrosion in the ice maker compartment. Older units may lack modern energy efficiency and water filtration features.
If your ice maker frequently jams or requires costly repairs, upgrading to a newer model with better technology often proves more economical. Consider replacement when the unit no longer meets your household's ice demand.
- Ice Quality Decline
- Frequent Breakdowns
- Energy Inefficiency
- Missing Features
1. Ice Quality Decline: Cloudy, odd-tasting, or misshapen ice indicating component wear
2. Frequent Breakdowns: Repeated ice maker jams or motor failures requiring service
3. Energy Inefficiency: Older models consuming significantly more electricity than current standards
4. Missing Features: Lack of self-cleaning, fast ice, or advanced filtration found in new models
