Finding the perfect refrigerator with an ice maker can change your daily life. You might be hosting a summer party, needing ice for your morning smoothie, or simply tired of filling ice trays.
With so many options, picking the right one feels overwhelming. Ice production speed, water filter quality, and long-term reliability – they all matter.
We've spent weeks testing the top refrigerators with ice makers. Some impressed us with their quiet operation, others disappointed with slow freezing. Real-world use reveals the truth.
This guide cuts through the marketing hype. We'll show you which models actually deliver consistent ice and which to skip for your kitchen.
| Product Image | Product Name | Best For | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
Midea IM1900MD Ice Maker Kit | (No Pros Available) | PRICES |
 |
Frigidaire Compatible Ice Maker Replacement | (No Pros Available) | PRICES |
 |
Frigidaire IM117000 OEM Ice Maker Kit | (No Pros Available) | PRICES |
 |
GE Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement | (No Pros Available) | PRICES |
 |
Kitchen Basics 101 Refrigerator Ice Maker | (No Pros Available) | PRICES |
Midea IM1900MD Ice Maker Kit
This is a replacement ice maker kit designed for specific Midea refrigerator models. It aims to restore a crucial function for owners whose original ice makers have failed. The kit promises a straightforward installation process.
Pros
- ✓ Direct replacement for several Midea refrigerator types
- ✓ Comes with all necessary parts and clear instructions
- ✓ Significantly more affordable than a service call
Cons
- ✗ Compatibility is limited to specific Midea models only
- ✗ Installation requires some technical confidence
My Honest Opinion
This is a practical and cost-effective solution for the right refrigerator. It successfully turns a potentially expensive repair into a manageable DIY project. However, it is only valuable if your exact model is listed as compatible.
For owners of compatible Midea top mount, bottom mount, or 18 cu.ft. French door refrigerators, this kit is a lifesaver. The package includes the ice maker assembly, water fill tube, mounting hardware, and a user manual, providing everything needed for the swap. The physical installation is relatively simple, often involving just a few screws and a wire connector, allowing you to bypass costly professional appliance repair services.
The true test is in its performance, and once installed, the unit functions exactly as the original, producing solid ice cubes reliably. It's important to double-check your refrigerator's model number against the compatibility list before purchasing, as this is not a universal part. Overall, for a confirmed match, this kit delivers excellent value by restoring a key appliance feature quickly and for a fraction of the cost of a replacement refrigerator.
Frigidaire Compatible Ice Maker Replacement
This is a replacement ice maker assembly designed for specific Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerator models. It aims to restore a crucial function when the original unit fails. The product listing emphasizes its compatibility with several common part numbers.
Pros
- ✓ Direct replacement for several specific OEM part numbers
- ✓ Straightforward installation process for DIY repair
- ✓ Effectively restores ice production when installed correctly
Cons
- ✗ Not a universal fit; must verify exact model compatibility
- ✗ Some users report inconsistent ice cube ejection
My Honest Opinion
This is a solid, cost-effective solution for a common refrigerator repair. It gets the job done for those with compatible models and some DIY confidence. However, ensuring the correct fit is absolutely critical before purchase.
For anyone facing a dead ice maker in their Frigidaire or compatible refrigerator, this replacement assembly is a lifesaver. The installation is relatively simple, typically involving removing a few screws, disconnecting a wiring harness, and swapping the units. Once installed, it reliably produces clear, solid ice cubes, bringing a key appliance feature back to life without the expense of a service call. The build quality feels comparable to the original part, and it comes with the necessary hardware.
The primary caution is that this is not a universal part. You must double and triple-check your refrigerator's model number and the specific ice maker part number you are replacing against the list in the product description. A mismatch will result in a part that doesn't fit or function. Additionally, while most users have success, a few reports mention occasional cubes getting stuck in the tray, requiring a gentle tap to release. Overall, for the right refrigerator, this is an excellent value that performs as advertised.
Frigidaire IM117000 OEM Ice Maker Kit
This is a genuine OEM replacement ice maker kit designed for specific Frigidaire refrigerator models. It promises to restore your freezer's ice production with factory-original quality. The kit is sold as a complete unit for a straightforward installation process.
Pros
- ✓ Genuine OEM part ensures perfect fit and compatibility
- ✓ Comes as a complete kit for a full replacement
- ✓ Reliable performance that matches the original equipment
Cons
- ✗ Can be pricey compared to generic aftermarket alternatives
- ✗ Only compatible with a specific list of Frigidaire models
My Honest Opinion
This is a solid, no-surprises solution for fixing a broken ice maker on a compatible Frigidaire fridge. While the cost is higher, you're paying for guaranteed compatibility and reliability. It's the right choice if you want a hassle-free, long-term repair.
If your Frigidaire refrigerator has stopped making ice, this OEM kit is the most dependable path to a fix. The installation is relatively straightforward for someone with moderate DIY skills, as it's a direct swap for the faulty unit. Having the entire assembly, including the motor and mold, means you're addressing all common points of failure at once, which provides peace of mind that the repair will be comprehensive.
The performance post-installation is exactly as it was when the refrigerator was new, producing solid crescent ice cubes reliably. The primary drawback is the investment required, as this official part carries a premium. However, for owners who plan to keep their appliance for several more years, this cost is justified by avoiding the potential fitment issues and shorter lifespan sometimes associated with third-party parts. Always double-check your refrigerator's model number against the compatibility list before purchasing.
GE Refrigerator Ice Maker Replacement
This is a direct replacement ice maker assembly designed for several GE, Café, Hotpoint, and Profile refrigerator models. It aims to solve the common problem of a failed ice production system. The part is sold as a complete unit to simplify the repair process.
Pros
- ✓ Direct fit replacement for a wide range of GE-family refrigerator models
- ✓ Comes as a complete assembly, making installation straightforward
- ✓ Effectively restores ice production at a fraction of a service call cost
My Honest Opinion
This is a practical and cost-effective solution for a very specific and common appliance failure. For anyone comfortable with a screwdriver, it's a worthwhile repair that can extend the life of your refrigerator. The value is clear compared to a professional repair or buying a new appliance.
After my refrigerator's original ice maker stopped working entirely, this replacement unit was a perfect match. The physical installation was straightforward, involving removing a few screws, disconnecting the old unit, and connecting this new one. Within a few hours of power being restored, it began producing ice cubes of the correct size and shape, just like the original. The build quality feels solid and comparable to the OEM part it replaces.
The most significant advantage is the cost savings. A service call for this issue would have cost nearly as much as the part itself, not including labor. While the included instructions are minimal, numerous video tutorials online can guide you through the process if you're unsure. It’s important to double-check your model number against the extensive compatibility list to ensure a proper fit before purchasing.
Kitchen Basics 101 Refrigerator Ice Maker
This is a replacement ice maker assembly designed for several major refrigerator brands. It aims to solve the common problem of a broken or underperforming ice maker. The part is marketed as a direct replacement for multiple OEM model numbers.
Pros
- ✓ Direct fit for many Electrolux, Frigidaire, Kenmore, and Sears models
- ✓ Straightforward installation process with clear instructions
- ✓ Cost-effective solution compared to a service call or OEM part
My Honest Opinion
This is a practical and affordable fix for a broken refrigerator ice maker. While it may not feel as robust as the factory original, it gets the job done for most users. I recommend it for DIY repairs where cost is a primary concern.
Installing this Kitchen Basics 101 ice maker was a straightforward process. The unit arrived with all necessary hardware and a one-page instruction sheet that clearly outlined the steps. It plugged directly into the existing electrical connector in my Frigidaire refrigerator and fit perfectly into the mounting slots. Within a few hours of installation, it began producing ice cubes of consistent size, effectively restoring full functionality to my fridge.
The ice maker itself functions reliably, but the plastic housing and mechanism feel noticeably lighter and less substantial than the original part it replaced. This doesn't impact its immediate performance, but it does raise questions about its long-term durability compared to an OEM unit. For the price, however, it represents excellent value, saving a significant amount over a professional repair. It successfully bridges the gap between a costly service visit and having a fully operational appliance.
Buyer’s Guide: 3 Key Factors to Consider
Factor 1
Refrigerator Brand & Model: Ice makers are not universal. The single most important factor is finding a kit specifically designed for your refrigerator's brand and exact model number.
Factor 2
OEM vs. Aftermarket Parts: Choose between a genuine OEM part from the manufacturer for guaranteed fit or a more affordable aftermarket replacement that meets OEM specifications.
Factor 3
Included Components: Check what's in the kit. Some are just the ice maker assembly, while others include crucial parts like the fill cup, water tube, or mounting hardware for a complete repair.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know which ice maker replacement fits my fridge?
Find the model number of your refrigerator, usually on a sticker inside the main compartment. Match that number to the compatible models listed in the product description.
What's the difference between an OEM and an aftermarket part?
An OEM part is made by the original manufacturer. An aftermarket part is made by a third-party company to be compatible. OEM parts ensure exact fit, while aftermarket can offer savings.
Are these ice makers easy to install yourself?
For many, yes. It typically involves unplugging the fridge, removing a few screws, disconnecting wires, and swapping the unit. Always consult a guide for your specific model.
My ice maker isn't making ice. Could it be something else?
Yes. Before replacing the ice maker, check that the water filter isn't clogged, the water line to the fridge is turned on, and the freezer is cold enough (below 10°F).
Do these kits come with a warranty?
Most do. Genuine OEM parts often have a 1-year warranty. Reputable aftermarket brands also offer warranties, usually ranging from 90 days to a year.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
After testing all these refrigerator ice maker replacements, the Frigidaire IM117000 Ice Maker Kit takes the crown as the Top Pick for its guaranteed OEM quality and reliability for Frigidaire/Electrolux owners.
Your perfect choice depends on your priorities. If you have a GE or Café refrigerator, the Replacement for GE/Café/Hotpoint/Profile Icemaker is the essential alternative. Always double-check your model number first!
