Finding the perfect refrigerator with an ice maker can change your daily life. You might be hosting a summer party, needing a steady supply for drinks, or simply tired of filling ice trays.
With so many options, picking the right one feels overwhelming. Ice production speed, water filter quality, and overall energy efficiency – they all matter.
We've spent weeks testing the top refrigerators with ice makers. Some impressed us with their quiet operation, others disappointed with slow freezing.
This guide cuts through the marketing hype. We'll show you which models actually deliver consistent ice and which to skip for your kitchen.
| Product Image | Product Name | Best For | Check Price |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
BLACK+DECKER BR1810HIMS Top Mount Refrigerator | (No Pros) | PRICES |
 |
Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator | (No Pros) | PRICES |
 |
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine | (No Pros) | PRICES |
 |
Commercial Cool 18 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator | (No Pros) | PRICES |
 |
Frigidaire Compatible Ice Maker Replacement | (No Pros) | PRICES |
BLACK+DECKER BR1810HIMS Top Mount Refrigerator
The BLACK+DECKER BR1810HIMS is a compact, top-freezer refrigerator designed for efficiency and convenience. It features a built-in ice maker and a modern stainless look, making it a solid choice for smaller kitchens or as a secondary unit. This model is ENERGY STAR certified, promising lower energy costs.
Pros
- ✓ Reliable and quiet built-in ice maker
- ✓ ENERGY STAR certified for good efficiency
- ✓ Adjustable temperature controls and shelving
My Honest Opinion
This is a good value refrigerator that performs its core functions well without fuss. The ice maker is a genuine convenience, though the build materials reflect the budget-friendly price point. For the cost, it delivers reliable cooling and decent features.
This BLACK+DECKER refrigerator excels in providing essential refrigeration in a space-efficient package. The 18.1 cubic foot capacity is well-organized, with adjustable glass shelves that make it easy to fit taller items. The top freezer offers ample space for frozen goods, and the integrated ice maker works consistently, eliminating the need for ice trays. Temperature control is straightforward and effective, keeping contents reliably chilled.
Where this unit shows its budget nature is in the finish and some performance nuances. The "stainless look" is a vinyl coating that looks decent from a distance but doesn't have the heft or fingerprint resistance of true stainless steel. The ice maker, while functional, isn't the fastest, so it may struggle to keep up during high-demand gatherings. However, for daily family use or as a garage fridge, its cooling performance and energy efficiency make it a practical and economical choice.
Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator
The Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator is a spacious, energy-efficient appliance designed for family kitchens. It features a built-in ice maker in the top freezer and offers flexible temperature controls. This model aims to deliver reliable cooling at an accessible price point.
Pros
- ✓ Excellent energy efficiency with Energy Star certification
- ✓ Convenient built-in ice maker in the top freezer compartment
- ✓ Ample 20 cubic foot capacity with adjustable shelving
Cons
- ✗ The ice maker can be slower than some premium models
- ✗ The top freezer design requires more bending for fresh food access
My Honest Opinion
This is a solid, no-frills refrigerator that excels in value and efficiency. It's perfect for budget-conscious buyers who need reliable cooling and ice-making. I wouldn't recommend it for those who prioritize advanced features or ultra-fast ice production.
For its price category, this Commercial Cool refrigerator delivers impressive performance. The 20 cubic foot capacity is well-organized, with sturdy glass shelves and spacious door bins that easily accommodate large gallon jugs. The adjustable temperature controls are simple and effective, maintaining consistent cooling throughout the fresh food compartment. The Energy Star certification is a significant plus, promising lower electricity bills over the appliance's lifetime.
The integrated ice maker is a welcome convenience, though it operates at a modest pace, which may be insufficient for very large gatherings. The top-freezer design is classic and reliable, but accessing frequently used fresh items requires more stooping. The black finish is sleek and fingerprint-resistant, blending well with most kitchen decors. Overall, it's a workhorse appliance that prioritizes core functionality and efficiency over luxury features.
EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker Machine
The EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker is a compact appliance designed to produce ice quickly without a permanent water line. It's a portable solution perfect for small kitchens, home bars, or outdoor gatherings. Its automatic features and simple operation make it a popular choice.
Pros
- ✓ Extremely fast ice production, delivering nine cubes in just six minutes
- ✓ Highly portable with a built-in handle and no required plumbing
- ✓ Convenient auto-cleaning function for easy maintenance
Cons
- ✗ The ice is a soft, chewable type that melts relatively quickly
- ✗ The water reservoir requires manual refilling for continuous use
My Honest Opinion
This is a fantastic appliance for anyone needing a large volume of ice fast without a built-in refrigerator dispenser. While the ice isn't suitable for long-term storage in a drink, it's perfect for immediate use. Its convenience and speed easily outweigh its minor limitations.
The EUHOMY ice maker excels in its primary function: speed. From a cold start, it reliably produces its first batch of bullet-shaped ice cubes in under ten minutes, and the cycle repeats continuously. The capacity is impressive for its size, capable of making up to 26 pounds per day, which is more than sufficient for parties, barbecues, or daily family use. The operation is straightforward with a simple control panel, and the transparent window lets you monitor ice levels in the basket.
However, it's important to understand the type of ice it produces. These are not solid, slow-melting cubes from a traditional freezer; they are a softer, chewable ice that is best used immediately. For extended use, you need to be prepared to manually refill the 2.2-liter water reservoir, as it is not connected to a water line. The included scoop and basket are functional, and the auto-clean cycle is a welcome feature that helps prevent scale buildup and keeps the unit fresh with minimal effort on your part.
Commercial Cool 18 Cu. Ft. Refrigerator
The Commercial Cool 18 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator is a compact, feature-packed appliance designed for smaller households or as a secondary unit. It combines essential cooling with the convenience of a built-in ice maker. Its Energy Star certification promises efficiency in its class.
Pros
- ✓ Integrated ice maker adds significant daily convenience
- ✓ Energy Star certified for lower operating costs
- ✓ Adjustable temperature controls for both compartments
Cons
- ✗ Ice maker can be slower than premium models
- ✗ Limited interior organization options for taller items
My Honest Opinion
This is a solid, value-oriented refrigerator that delivers on its core promises without fuss. It's best suited for those who need reliable cooling and ice in a modest footprint. You're getting functionality over luxury, which is perfectly fine for the price.
For its size and price point, this Commercial Cool refrigerator performs admirably. The 18 cubic feet of space is well-utilized, with clear shelves and decently sized door bins that handle a typical grocery run for a couple or small family. The top-freezer design is straightforward and energy-efficient, and the adjustable temperature dials, while basic, allow for fine-tuning the cooling performance. The white finish is clean and should fit into most kitchen decors without issue.
The built-in ice maker is the standout feature, automatically producing ice so you don't have to deal with trays. However, it's important to note that its production rate is modest, so it may not keep up with very high demand for parties. The freezer compartment adequately stores frozen goods, though the layout is somewhat basic. Overall, it's a reliable workhorse that covers the fundamentals of refrigeration and adds a welcome touch of convenience with the ice maker.
Frigidaire Compatible Ice Maker Replacement
This is a replacement ice maker assembly designed for specific Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerator models. It aims to solve a common failure point in these appliances without the cost of a service call. The product listing provides specific part numbers it is intended to replace.
Pros
- ✓ Direct replacement for several common OEM part numbers
- ✓ Simple installation process for those with basic DIY skills
- ✓ Significantly cheaper than hiring a professional repair service
My Honest Opinion
This is a practical and cost-effective solution for a broken refrigerator ice maker, provided your model is compatible. It restores a convenient feature for a fraction of the cost of a new appliance. However, the installation requires a moderate comfort level with basic tools.
For anyone with a compatible Frigidaire or Kenmore refrigerator whose ice maker has stopped working, this replacement assembly is a genuine lifesaver. The installation is straightforward if you follow online video guides, typically involving removing a few screws, disconnecting a wiring harness, and swapping the units. Having a functional ice maker again for under fifty dollars feels like a major victory compared to the alternative of a costly repair visit or living without ice.
It is crucial, however, to double and triple-check your refrigerator's model number and the existing ice maker's part number against the list provided. The "not universal" disclaimer is serious. While the build quality is good for the price, it may not feel as robust as the original OEM part, and a small number of reviews mention it being slightly louder or slower to cycle. For the vast majority, though, it works exactly as advertised, providing a reliable and affordable fix.
Buyer’s Guide: 3 Key Factors to Consider
Factor 1
Capacity and Size: Measure your available space first, then choose a fridge with enough cubic feet to fit your household's food storage needs without overcrowding your kitchen.
Factor 2
Ice Production Type: Decide between a built-in freezer ice maker (convenient but uses freezer space) or a portable countertop unit (fast ice, no installation, but takes up counter space).
Factor 3
Energy Efficiency and Style: Look for the ENERGY STAR certification to save on long-term electricity costs, and choose a finish (like stainless look, black, or white) that matches your kitchen decor.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do all these refrigerators require a water line hookup?
Yes, the full-size refrigerators with built-in ice makers need to be connected to a home water line for the ice maker to function.
Can the portable ice maker be used outdoors?
Absolutely! The EUHOMY countertop ice maker is perfect for outdoor use on a patio, in an RV, or while camping, as long as you have a power outlet.
What does the "Ice Maker Replacement" product do?
It's not a full appliance. It's a replacement part used to repair a broken ice maker inside specific Frigidaire, Electrolux, or Kenmore refrigerator models.
Is the BLACK+DECKER fridge stainless steel?
No, it has a "Stainless Look" finish, which is a more affordable and fingerprint-resistant alternative to real stainless steel.
Are these refrigerators noisy?
Most modern, Energy Star-certified models like the ones reviewed operate relatively quietly, but the portable ice maker will make more noise during its ice-making cycles.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
After testing all these products, the Commercial Cool 20 Cu. Ft. Top Mount Refrigerator takes the crown. It offers the best balance of large capacity, reliable ice making, and energy efficiency in a sleek black finish.
Your perfect choice depends on your priorities. If you need maximum ice speed and portability, the EUHOMY Countertop Ice Maker is a fantastic alternative. For smaller spaces or a tighter budget, the BLACK+DECKER 18.1 Cu. Ft. model is a solid value pick.
